Back to Latest
News Nov 16, 2026

Turkish courts refuse to apply ECtHR Grand Chamber ruling in Osman Kavala case, deny retrial and release

The European Court of Human Rights’ Grand Chamber found on 25 August 2026 that Osman Kavala’s conviction and continued detention violated the European Convention and amounted to a denial of justice, yet Turkish criminal courts have declined to order a retrial or his immediate release. Domestic courts said domestic remedies were not exhausted — pointing to pending individual applications to the Constitutional Court — even though those applications have gone undecided for years.

By Clémence Desjardins 1,181 views
Turkish courts refuse to apply ECtHR Grand Chamber ruling in Osman Kavala case, deny retrial and release
Turkish criminal courts have rejected calls to reopen the case of prominent rights defender Osman Kavala and to order his immediate release, even after the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) Grand Chamber issued a final decision finding multiple violations related to his conviction and continued detention. The clash exposes a deepening standoff between national judicial practice in Turkey and the country’s obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights.

Kavala was convicted by the Istanbul 13th Heavy Penal Court on 25 April 2022 under Article 312 of the Turkish Penal Code and sentenced to aggravated life imprisonment, according to the domestic case file (case file no. 2021/178, decision no. 2022/178). His conviction was dismissed on appeal by the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal’s 3rd Criminal Chamber on 28 December 2022, and subsequently the Court of Cassation’s 3rd Criminal Chamber upheld the conviction on 28 September 2023, rendering the judgment final.

On 25 August 2026 the ECtHR Grand Chamber (Kavala v. Turkey (No. 2), Application No. 2170/24) concluded that the conviction and ongoing detention of Kavala were incompatible with the European Convention. The Grand Chamber found that the prosecution, detention and conviction were carried out with the aim of punishing and silencing Kavala for views he had expressed as a human rights defender and determined there had been a violation of Article 18 of the Convention. The Court described the conviction that deprived Kavala of his liberty as “a denial of justice” and held that it lacked any legal basis.

Following the ECtHR decision, lawyers for Kavala sought reopening of his trial and suspension of execution of the sentence, requesting his immediate release on 8 September 2026. Instead, Istanbul 13th Heavy Penal Court issued an “additional” decision on 13 October 2026 refusing both retrial and release. The court said the application was premature because domestic remedies, including appeal avenues and the individual application to the Constitutional Court, had not been exhausted.

The 13th Court framed its refusal as a defense of national sovereignty and judicial competence, warning that accepting a retrial request before domestic remedies were exhausted would allow “an international court to exceed its competence and interfere with the independent exercise of a sovereign state’s judicial authority.” The court characterized the ECtHR as having acted beyond its remit by issuing a decision without awaiting completion of domestic procedures.

An appeal against that refusal was examined by Istanbul 14th Heavy Penal Court, which on 13 November 2026 dismissed the objection. The 14th Chamber relied on ECtHR precedent, citing the Hasan Uzun v. Turkey decision, to uphold the proposition that an application to the ECtHR presupposes the exhaustion of domestic remedies — including the route of individual application to the Constitutional Court — before a retrial can be ordered by national judges. The panel concluded that because Kavala had not exhausted those domestic procedures, the 13th Court’s additional decision was procedurally sound.

The domestic courts’ reliance on the exhaustion rule is complicated, however, by the fact that Kavala had lodged individual applications to the Constitutional Court on 9 June 2022 and 25 July 2023. Those applications remain undecided, according to the record, and have been pending for years. The ECtHR itself has previously recognized that the effectiveness of domestic remedies must be assessed in light of the circumstances of the case. In the Hasan Uzun judgment cited by the Turkish courts, the ECtHR stressed that it retains the authority to evaluate whether the domestic avenue — here, individual application to the Constitutional Court — is effective in practice, not merely in theory.

In the Kavala Grand Chamber judgment the ECtHR explicitly analyzed whether waiting for a Constitutional Court decision would have been effective in the specific circumstances. The Court found that prolonged inaction by the Constitutional Court and the exceptional features of the underlying proceedings meant that Kavala could not reasonably be required to await a domestic ruling. The ECtHR concluded that, given the exceptional delay and the risk of rendering the remedy ineffective, Kavala’s resort to the Strasbourg court was justified.

Legal commentators and rights activists warn that the domestic rulings rejecting retrial set a worrying precedent: by treating ECtHR judgments as present but not operational, national courts risk constructing a parallel legal order in which supranational rights protections are acknowledged in principle but denied in practice. If individual application to the Constitutional Court becomes, in practice, an ineffective remedy because of prolonged inaction, the protective function of the European Convention system will be undermined. For rights defenders and lawyers who rely on both domestic and international avenues to secure redress, the dispute highlights a crucial question: when domestic remedies are so delayed that they cannot meaningfully vindicate rights, can — and should — national courts allow international judgments to trigger immediate domestic corrective measures such as retrial and release?

The Kavala litigation remains a live and contentious test of Turkey’s willingness and ability to implement final ECtHR judgments. The conflict between the ECtHR’s finding of Article 18 violations and the domestic courts’ insistence on procedural exhaustion underscores the broader tensions over the rule of law, judicial independence and the enforceability of international human rights obligations within Turkey’s legal system.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE