South Africa rejects appeal to export five baobab trees to Georgia as criminal probe continues
South African authorities have refused an appeal to allow the export of five uprooted baobab trees to Georgia after halting the shipment in July amid questions over whether the trees were felled and moved illegally. The trees remain outside a Durban warehouse while investigators consider criminal charges that could carry fines or up to three years' imprisonment; experts warn the plants must be replanted quickly to survive.
By Alexander Walter
1,091 views
South African authorities have denied an appeal by an unidentified exporter to send five uprooted baobab trees to Georgia, saying the planned export remains halted while a criminal investigation continues. The Department for Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment (DFFE) stopped the shipment in July on suspicion that the trees may have been felled and transported illegally and told OC Media the appeal was submitted on 8 August and subsequently refused.
The five large baobab specimens—trees that can live for centuries and, in some cases, millennia—have been photographed sitting on hot tarmac outside a warehouse in the port city of Durban. Local reporting by Daily Maverick said the trees had been in that location for almost three months. According to the DFFE, the trees were harvested in the Lephalale Local Municipality in the Waterberg District of Limpopo province and were scheduled for export to Georgia, Europe.
Authorities have indicated that, if convicted, the exporter could be guilty of a 'first category offence' and face a penalty of a fine or imprisonment for a period of up to three years, or both. The department also told OC Media that because the matter is under criminal investigation it would not issue a licence retrospectively to regularise what may be illegal activity.
Africa Global Logistics (AGL), the owner of the Durban warehouse where the trees are being held, told OC Media it is not the owner, exporter or permit holder for the trees and did not move them from Limpopo. AGL said that ‘‘when concerns about the regulatory documentation’’ came to light they ‘‘stopped the proposed shipment’’. The company said it has cooperated with the relevant authorities and will continue to do so, adding that no criminal charges have been brought against AGL in this matter.
The situation has prompted concern from conservationists and tree specialists about the immediate welfare of the uprooted plants. Christopher Dalzell, a former botanical garden curator and an expert in tree transport, offered pro bono assistance to authorities to replant the trees and warned that they ‘‘have to go somewhere else very quickly. They will die unless they get to a botanical garden or specialist nursery’’. Dalzell stressed that removal from the warehouse asphalt and careful replanting are urgent if the trees are to survive.
Dr Sarah Venter of the Baobab Foundation, speaking to OC Media, estimated from photographs that the trees are between 200 and 300 years old. She noted that while baobabs are succulents and therefore ‘‘technically really easy to uproot and replant somewhere else’’, past experience in Georgia has been mixed. ‘‘Georgia has not had a good track record keeping these trees alive,’’ Dr Venter said, adding that ‘‘the best solution for these trees is to be replanted in South Africa, rather than being exported to Georgia’’. The trees’ indigenous status and the role of baobab fruit in rural economies have contributed to local outrage over their harvesting.
The case also invokes recent, high-profile attempts to transplant baobabs to Georgia. In one example cited by conservation commentators, eight baobab trees imported from Kenya to the Shekvetili Dendrological Park in 2023 died the following year; the park, founded by billionaire and political figure Bidzina Ivanishvili, subsequently blamed the opposition United National Movement for the deaths. Despite that failure and tighter restrictions in some source countries such as Kenya, some Georgian landscapers and private projects are reported to remain interested in acquiring baobabs.
OC Media has sought comment from representatives linked to the Georgian projects and to Bidzina Ivanishvili; the DFFE has not named the exporter and did not suggest the Durban trees were connected to any particular Georgian landscaping initiative. For now, the five baobabs remain under the control of South African authorities as investigators pursue enquiries into how and by whom they were felled and transported. The outcome of that probe will determine whether criminal charges are brought and what will ultimately happen to the trees, whose survival depends on prompt and expert replanting.