Back to Latest
News Nov 6, 2026

EU defends age ‘staircase’ for children’s social media as national bans show gaps

More than 20 countries are restricting children’s access to social media, but questions remain over whether bans actually protect young people or simply push them towards less regulated platforms. As the EU develops its own age-based restrictions, evidence from Australia and Albania highlights the challenges of enforcement, while researchers argue that safer platform design may be the more effective solution.

By Klaudjo Jonuzaj 891 views
EU defends age ‘staircase’ for children’s social media as national bans show gaps
Photo: Marijan Murat, Picture Alliance via Getty Images
More than 20 countries have moved to block or restrict children’s access to social media, according to an AFP tally published by Ireland’s broadcaster RTE, yet child-rights groups, researchers and platforms disagree over whether bans protect children or push the problem elsewhere. Supporters, driven heavily by parental advocacy groups, cite a youth mental-health crisis, predatory behaviour and addictive design. Opponents say bans address access, not design, and are easily bypassed.

Individual cases have shaped that argument. A 20-year-old woman identified in court as KGM told a Los Angeles jury she began using YouTube at six and Instagram at nine and spent up to 16 hours a day on social platforms, Euronews reported. In March the jury found Meta and YouTube liable, putting 70% of the responsibility on Meta. Both deny wrongdoing and plan to appeal.

In Britain, the debate has been shaped by the death of Molly Russell, who was 14 when she took her own life in 2017 after viewing harmful material on social media. Her father, Ian Russell, who founded the Molly Rose Foundation, told LBC that a blanket ban would be “an admission of failure” by government.

Governments have nonetheless moved towards restrictions. Australia, the first to act, banned under-16s from holding accounts in December 2025. By June more than five million accounts had been deactivated, according to reporting republished by the University of Sydney, but the regulator’s own compliance report found that about 70% of children who held accounts were still using them. That gap between accounts closed and children actually offline sits at the centre of the debate.

Europe is now testing a different route. At EU level, the European Commission in September put forward the EU KIDS Act, which would bar accounts for children under 13, set 15 as the minimum age for independent accounts and require safety by design, according to the Commission’s press release. An expert panel had recommended 13, the EU’s diplomatic service (EEAS) said.

In an exclusive response to The Liberty Bulletin, European Commission Spokesperson Thomas Regnier stressed that the proposal is still a work in progress: “the EU KIDS Act is a draft legislation, which is now in negotiations with the co-legislators.” The reply was on the record and attributable to Regnier.

Asked what evidence supports the proposal, Regnier said it “rests on a broad evidence base”. He pointed to the report of the Special Panel of independent experts, dedicated consultations with children, parents and educators, and years of Digital Services Act implementation and enforcement, including ten preliminary findings concerning the protection of minors. He also cited the process behind the Commission’s Guidelines on protection of minors online.

On the age thresholds, Regnier said the “gradual approach” follows the recommendations of the Special Panel on children’s safety online: a harmonised minimum age combined with parental guidance and evolving capacities. The proposal, he said, “establishes gradual autonomy, starting at 13”. Children under 13 would have no accounts. At 13, exposure “can begin in a limited way”, through an account the parent sets up and controls, with parental tools always on and a daily time limit. From 15, minors “act autonomously, in an environment that is finally safe by design”. Regnier described the model as “a staircase that follows how children grow up, not a single cliff-edge at any one age.”

The proposal also leans on the bloc’s age-verification technology, which Regnier said sets the standards the Commission’s text is based on. He described the EU age verification app as “user friendly, open-source and with the highest privacy standards”, and said the Commission has presented the technical work, which member states may now produce as a standalone app or integrate into their own solutions. It is based on “zero knowledge proof”, he said, and is “fully privacy-preserving”. Users download the national app and certify their age, either through another app such as a banking app or physically at a government agency or a post office. Once the app receives that certification, the link with the proof provider is cut, and no personal data or ID is stored in the app. When presented to an online service, it simply confirms whether the user meets the age requirement. “The platform will not receive any information about the user,” Regnier said.

The Commission is also keen to head off a patchwork of national rules. Brussels earlier cautioned that extra national obligations on platforms can clash with the Digital Services Act, Euronews reported in February. Asked about national draft laws, Regnier said the EU KIDS Act introduces a gradual approach to children’s social media accounts and “safety by design” to online services, and that it harmonises the rules so that all children in the EU are safer in the digital world. “Because a European problem requires a united European solution,” he said. It was crucial, he added, “to avoid a fragmentation of our internal market, preserve the work of our co-legislators, and ensure effective enforcement of the EU legislative framework”. He called on all member states “to engage faithfully in the KIDS Act negotiations.”

Enforcement is where national experience is most instructive. Albania, an EU candidate country, ran a version of the experiment, although its measure was broader than an age limit. After a 14-year-old boy was fatally stabbed by a fellow pupil in November 2024 following a dispute that local media said began online, the government blocked TikTok for all users for one year from March 13, 2025, Reuters reported. TikTok has disputed that the incident began on its platform. The block was easily bypassed: Brenton Benja of Geek Room Albania told Reuters it had limited impact because people used VPNs, and Swiss provider Proton reported a 1,200% jump in VPN sign-ups on the eve of the ban, Politika reported. When the ban was repealed in early February 2026, the government told Reuters that TikTok had tightened safety measures. Digital rights researcher Megi Reçi told Osservatorio Balcani e Caucaso Transeuropa (OBCT), however, that no public report assessed the ban’s effectiveness, and that the lack of evidence of improvement makes it debatable whether it achieved its goals. OBCT also reported that no consultation reports were published.

Enforcement is also where the platforms push back. They accept age limits in principle but contest who should be responsible. Meta, X and Snap urged app stores to verify ages, TechInformed reported, while Google, which runs the Play Store, called that a “cynical attempt to shift responsibility”, CTV News reported.

Child-rights groups, for their part, largely warn against blanket bans. UNICEF said bans “may even backfire”, UN News reported, noting that isolated or marginalised children often rely on social media. Amnesty International UK called the British plan “the right diagnosis but the wrong prescription”, arguing that the problem is platforms designed to be unsafe.

Researchers who study what children actually see add a further warning. Dublin City University researchers found that after about 400 videos on simulated teenage-boy accounts, 76% of recommended TikTok content and 78% on YouTube Shorts was toxic or problematic. Maja Brandt Andreasen, one of the researchers who worked on the study (DCU Recommending Toxicity Report), told The Liberty Bulletin in written answers that “all research indicates that a ban would only mean that the under-16s move to other and more unregulated platforms.”

Asked how far simulated accounts can speak for real teenagers, she said the study gives “an idea of the type of experiences young people can have on social media” but cannot show exactly what happens or to what extent. Other research, in which teenagers donate their data and scrolling behaviour and are interviewed, shows that their experiences and the content they see are “very similar” to what the study found, she said.

On what matters more for protecting children, Andreasen said the priority is changing recommender systems and holding tech companies responsible for the content on their platforms. Before other countries follow Australia, she said she would want evidence that teenagers do not simply move their digital lives to other, unrestricted and more extreme platforms, and longitudinal studies showing that a ban does not harm their social lives.

The scientific picture on mental health is less settled. Psychologist Candice Odgers says the data on social media and youth mental health show small, mixed and mostly correlational associations, Sherwood News reported.

Supporters and sceptics agree that platform design is at the heart of the problem, and researchers such as Andreasen argue that is where the remedy lies. The open question is whether keeping children out buys time to fix it or merely pushes them somewhere less safe. Evidence from Australia and Albania suggests bans leak, and Albania shows a second weakness: a ban lifted without a public assessment leaves citizens unable to judge what it achieved. The Commission’s answer, a staircase of rules still in negotiation, has yet to be tested.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE