Back to Latest
News Nov 5, 2026

Daghestani law professor urges lighter sentences for blood-feud killings, sparking backlash

A Daghestani professor has proposed downgrading Russia’s sentencing for murders committed in blood-feud contexts, arguing the custom can deter crime and provide restorative outcomes. The suggestion, made at a Moscow State University seminar, drew criticism from the Presidential Council for Human Rights and prompted Daghestan State University to distance itself from the remarks.

By Clémence Desjardins 961 views
Daghestani law professor urges lighter sentences for blood-feud killings, sparking backlash
A senior legal scholar from Daghestan has proposed reducing criminal penalties for murders carried out as part of blood feuds, a move that has provoked criticism from government human rights advisers and prompted her university to distance itself from her comments. Dureya Ziyadova, a Doctor of Law and professor at Daghestan State University, made the suggestion during a research meeting at the Criminal Law School of the Faculty of Law at Moscow State University devoted to the legal, criminological and psychological aspects of blood feuds.

Under current Russian criminal law, murder motivated by a blood feud is treated as an aggravating circumstance under the murder article and carries a sentence of eight to 20 years in prison or life imprisonment. Ziyadova proposed reclassifying such crimes under a different clause of the same article that prescribes lighter penalties — six to 15 years’ imprisonment — arguing that the present provision breaches the principle of equality before the law.

Opening the seminar, Ziyadova described blood feud customs as having a “significant preventive potential.” She told participants that, unlike formal state justice, these community practices can secure compensation, elicit apologies from perpetrators and bring about sincere repentance. In an interview with pro-government outlet Readovka, she called blood feuds a “positive phenomenon” and suggested the fear of retaliation might deter criminal behaviour in Daghestan, Chechnya and Ingushetia.

Ziyadova did not provide empirical evidence that the threat of blood feud directly lowers crime rates. Human rights defenders monitoring the North Caucasus generally attribute reported low crime statistics to factors such as unreported offences and low levels of alcohol consumption rather than extrajudicial retribution. Nevertheless, Ziyadova compared the custom to benign cultural rituals and rejected characterisations of the practice as vigilantism, saying that communities often know the perpetrator and that a confession by the accused can render a court unnecessary.

Her remarks drew swift institutional pushback. Daghestan State University told Readovka that its leadership did not share Ziyadova’s position, that her comments had been forwarded to the rector’s office, and that an official statement would be prepared. Eva Merkacheva, a member of the Presidential Council for Civil Society and Human Rights, publicly opposed any easing of penalties. Merkacheva said that treating blood-feud-motivated murders as an aggravating circumstance had been instrumental in curbing the practice and that national customs and traditions must not supersede federal law. According to the council’s press service, other seminar participants sided with Merkacheva.

The discussion at the Moscow seminar included other academics who acknowledged the restorative aspects some communities associate with traditional reconciliation. Professors Elmira Dzhakhieva and Siyabshakh Shapiev and Chechen academic Dzhambulat Saidumov spoke of the role of custom in deterrence and social justice, while Rustem Maksudov, chair of the All-Russian Association for Restorative Mediation, noted similarities between traditional reconciliation procedures and restorative-justice models. Saidumov additionally made the contested claim that Chechen women were particularly protected under the rules of blood feud, though he suggested that men in women’s families could still be held to account.

The debate about blood feuds in Russia’s North Caucasus has a long and violent history. High-profile feuds and revenge killings have included the protracted confrontation between the Yamadaev and Kadyrov families in Chechnya, which involved the 2008 killing of MP Ruslan Yamadaev in Moscow and later attacks on his relatives abroad. In 2024, Ramzan Kadyrov himself declared a blood feud in a separate dispute over business ownership against several federal lawmakers. More broadly, episodes such as the 2004 killing of Swiss air traffic controller Peter Nielsen by Vitaly Kaloev — who blamed Nielsen for a 2002 mid-air collision that killed Kaloev’s family — illustrate how private vengeance can intersect with criminal justice, media narratives and political rehabilitation.

Legal experts and rights activists say the core issue is whether customary mechanisms for dealing with serious crimes should be accommodated within a system that must guarantee equality, accountability and prevention of violence. Proposals to soften penalties for killings tied to blood feuds raise questions about the state’s monopoly on legitimate use of force, the protection of victims’ rights, and the potential legitimisation of extrajudicial retribution under the guise of cultural tradition. As debate continues, the university’s distancing and the Presidential Council’s opposition suggest significant institutional resistance to any legal rollback that might undermine federal criminal standards.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE