Back to Latest
News Sep 26, 2026

Court finds rights violation in denial of visits to political prisoner Azat Miftakhov but rejects claims of staff misconduct and grants no compensation

A Labytangi city court has ruled that political prisoner and mathematician Azat Miftakhov suffered a violation of his rights after prison authorities denied his wife access to the correctional colony on multiple occasions. The court declined to find prison staff actions unlawful and refused to award compensation, while earlier allegations by Miftakhov of torture and ill-treatment remain contested.

By Christopher Manley 1,126 views
Court finds rights violation in denial of visits to political prisoner Azat Miftakhov but rejects claims of staff misconduct and grants no compensation
A court in the Siberian town of Labytangi has recognized that the rights of political prisoner and mathematician Azat Miftakhov were violated when prison authorities repeatedly denied his wife access to the correctional colony, but the ruling stopped short of granting him compensation or finding individual officers culpable.

The decision, delivered on September 24, related to several instances in which the colony refused to admit Miftakhov’s wife, Lena Gorban, for visits. According to reporting, the court concluded that denying her entry as a legal representative on four occasions amounted to a breach of his rights. Despite that finding, the court rejected broader claims that prison employees had acted unlawfully in their treatment of Miftakhov and did not award any financial compensation for the established violation.

Miftakhov himself has described harsh conditions and mistreatment during his incarceration. He has alleged that on at least one occasion a prison officer forced him outside during heavy rain into an area without a drainage system and mocked him with words to the effect of “I hope you can swim.” To avoid getting drenched, Miftakhov said, he had to climb onto a bench and wait outside the cell for about an hour. The colony administration and the Federal Penitentiary Service (FSIN) responded to inquiries from Miftakhov’s wife by stating that all the exercise yards in the colony were similar, and that Miftakhov had been warned about the possibility of becoming wet while outside. The colony’s leadership has also denied that an officer asked Miftakhov whether he could swim.

Miftakhov has made far more serious allegations of physical abuse. He reported that upon his arrival on April 21 at the IK-18 “Polar Owl” penal colony in Kharp, he was subjected to torture, including electric shocks, having his legs bound with adhesive tape, being struck on the heels with a wooden hammer, and being threatened with sexual violence. He named several correctional officers he said were involved in the alleged mistreatment. Investigative outlet The Insider subsequently identified two FSIN employees whom Miftakhov had mentioned: Mikhail Sobolev from Tyumen and Pavel Kiselev from Sverdlovsk. Those allegations were explicit and serious, but the court dismissed them.

Court proceedings were not without procedural problems. During a hearing on September 22, the judge left the courtroom to consider a decision, and the videoconference link handling remote participation was cut. Miftakhov’s legal team refused to participate in further hearings under those conditions, while Miftakhov himself stated he would not answer questions without his lawyer present.

Miftakhov, now in his eighth year of imprisonment, was initially sentenced to six years on hooliganism charges. He was previously detained and served time at IK-17, a correctional colony in the Kirov region, and was detained again on September 4, 2023, after his release from IK-17. Despite the limitations and the contested circumstances of his detention and transfer, he has continued to conduct mathematical research while incarcerated. Relatives and supporters have helped transmit his work to academic journals abroad: in August a paper by Miftakhov, titled roughly “Chu’s conjecture in Hilbert space,” was published in the French mathematics journal Revue de la filière mathématiques (RMS). This is not his first publication from prison; earlier work appeared in the Bulletin of the Polish Academy of Sciences. Mathematics and in Rivista di Matematica dell’Università di Parma.

Human rights advocates and observers say the case underscores broader concerns about due process, conditions of detention, and monitoring of alleged ill-treatment in Russian prisons. The court’s limited finding — acknowledging a procedural violation related to visits but rejecting claims of torture and refusing compensation — leaves many questions about accountability and oversight unanswered. For Miftakhov and his supporters, the ruling is a partial vindication that does not address the more serious accusations of physical abuse brought against correctional staff. FSIN’s denials and the court’s ruling together indicate that further legal and investigative scrutiny would be required to substantiate or refute the most serious allegations in an environment where independent oversight is limited.

The case continues to draw attention from human rights groups, independent media and the academic community abroad because it combines allegations of rights violations with the imprisonment of an academic whose legal situation and treatment in custody raise questions about access to counsel, family visits and safeguards against abuse in corrective institutions.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE