Almaty court orders journalist Vadim Boreiko to pay 43 million tenge to construction company and remove online reports
An Almaty district court on November 13 ruled that independent journalist Vadim Boreiko must pay 43 million tenge to a construction firm and take down and retract his online reports about a housing project. The decision stems from a defamation complaint by Etude-Ybyrai over seven videos about the Premier residential complex; Boreiko and his supporters say he was reporting on public-interest issues using official sources.
By Clémence Desjardins
951 views
An Almaty court has ordered independent journalist Vadim Boreiko to pay 43 million tenge to a construction company and to remove and publish retractions of online materials, in a ruling delivered on November 13. The Bostandyk District Court read its decision in a civil complaint brought by the Etude-Ybyrai construction company, which argued that a series of reports published on Boreiko’s “Giperborey” (Hyperborey) YouTube channel damaged its business reputation and caused financial loss.
According to the court and subsequent statements from the Almaty City Court press service, judges examined evidence and the results of court-ordered expert assessments and concluded that the information Boreiko published was not true. A court-financed economic expert report found that the spread of allegedly false information caused losses to the company — referred to in some court documents as “T” LLP — amounting to more than 43 million tenge. The press service said that once the ruling takes legal effect, Boreiko must remove the contested materials from YouTube and Instagram and publish a formal retraction within ten days.
Etude-Ybyrai initially sought roughly 71 million tenge in compensation and demanded retractions. The company’s complaint centered on seven video materials on the Premier residential complex that aired on the Giperborey channel. The company accused the journalist of spreading false information and harming its business reputation.
Boreiko’s legal team contested the company’s claims. Defense lawyers argued that Boreiko was reporting on a matter of public interest and relied on official responses — including replies from the State Architecture and Construction Control Department and statements by former Almaty mayor Erbolat Dosaev. They said the journalist gave both sides of the story a chance to comment and did not add his own assertions beyond those official sources. The defense also challenged the court-appointed economic expert’s attribution of the company’s losses directly to the journalist’s reporting.
Supporters of Boreiko gathered at the courthouse on the day the decision was announced. The ruling coincided with Boreiko’s birthday; in the days preceding the hearing a false online notice circulated claiming a memorial event for the journalist would be held, which Boreiko later said appeared designed to intimidate. He wrote that the fake message even presented itself as if posted from his Telegram channel.
The court decision is the latest development in a series of incidents and pressures surrounding the veteran journalist. Boreiko, a journalist for more than four decades who has worked for outlets including Vremya, Forbes.kz and Ratel.kz, built a following on YouTube for critical reporting on officials and public institutions. Earlier this year his social media accounts on Facebook and Instagram were reportedly hacked. In 2023, unknown assailants glued the door of his apartment with construction material, and his colleague — videographer Roman Egorov — experienced arson attacks on two vehicles, which Egorov said he believed were connected to his professional work.
Authorities in Almaty have also faced criticism for lenient sentences in attacks on journalists. In the autumn following those incidents, an Almaty court issued suspended sentences to people accused of organizing attacks on journalists; court documents and reporting indicated those convicted were also implicated in other assaults on media workers.
Boreiko had announced in early September that he was suspending activity on his YouTube channel for an unspecified period. With the new court judgment ordering financial compensation and removal of material, the case raises broader concerns among press freedom advocates about the use of civil litigation and economic damage claims to curtail critical reporting in Kazakhstan. The ruling’s immediate practical impact requires Boreiko to comply with content removal and retraction requirements if the decision becomes final and enforceable.